A3 THINKING DYNAMICS: A CAFÉ
The A3 Thinking exercise is a method that can be applied to various scenarios. In this case, it is used to optimise the operational system of a café. The exercise is designed as a structured discovery process, guiding participants from understanding the problem to taking action.
OBJECTIVES AND LEARNING
Making decisions quickly often leads to a poorly defined problem and jumping to conclusions too soon. In this context, the A3 helps to structure both the problem definition and the identification of the actions to be implemented. Using it systematically allows us to dig deeper, layer by layer, until we reach the root causes of the situation. To apply it rigorously and effectively, and to avoid rushing to solutions, it is essential to have the support of a mentor who guides the process and helps to avoid taking shortcuts in the analysis.
STEP-BY-STEP APPLICATION
The facilitator divides the group into teams of four and explains the problem to be solved: improving the profitability of a café located in a small town which, for some strange reason, is unable to maintain the results it achieved when it first opened:
- Next, each team brainstorms to identify the main problems and their possible causes without any additional information. To aid the analysis, it is recommended that an Ishikawa diagram be used to organise the potential causes.
- Once this initial analysis has been carried out, the facilitator provides a structured explanation of how the A3 format works, and its various sections.
- Later, in a second phase, the participants, working in groups, can ask the facilitator questions to obtain further details about the case.
- The information is not provided transparently from the outset. It is only made available in response to questions raised by the teams, using the attached cards, whose purpose is to clarify the current situation before proposing alternatives. Should the facilitator not have any of the requested information, they will inform the team accordingly.
Finally, the conclusions drawn in the A3 are compared with the initial hypotheses put forward in the Ishikawa diagram, highlighting the lessons learnt during the process.
The facilitator will act as the café owner and will provide a diagram of the café to explain the team’s roles and workload.

INFORMATION SHEETS (CUT OUT AND HAND OUT ON REQUEST)
The facilitator plays the role of the café owner and will provide the information requested by each team using cards, if requested:

INFORMATION SHEETS (CUT OUT AND HAND OUT ON REQUEST)
The facilitator plays the role of the café owner and will provide the information requested by each team using cards, if requested:

INFORMATION SHEETS (CUT OUT AND HAND OUT ON REQUEST)
The facilitator plays the role of the café owner and will provide the information requested by each team using cards, if requested:

INFORMATION SHEETS (CUT OUT AND HAND OUT ON REQUEST)
The facilitator plays the role of the café owner and will provide the information requested by each team using cards, if requested:

FACILITATOR'S GUIDE
The facilitator can use the following guide to support the teams. They are not expected to provide solutions, but help by asking questions that guide the analysis.
FACILITATOR'S GUIDE
- Has the issue been clearly identified?
- Have the objectives been set?
- Has the current situation been described?
- Has the issue to be addressed been prioritised?
- ¿Cuál es el problema que debemos abordar?
- Are the facts and figures clear?
- Has the root cause been identified?
- Is the problem described correctly (what, why, when, how, where and who)?
- Have the relevant factors been taken into account?
- How will the causes be investigated?
- If there are several problems, which is the main one?
- Have any countermeasures or actions been identified?
- Will these measures prevent the problem from recurring?
- How will the results be verified?
CONCLUSIONS
The exercise begins with an overview of the café that is to be improved. It is a ground-floor premises, with space for eight tables and around twenty chairs.
The counters with the coffee machines are located on the left-hand side of the premises, whilst the customer service counter is on the right. The premises also have a small kitchen equipped with a fridge where the milk is stored; it is then taken to the coffee machine area in one-litre jugs to use during service.
Based on this description, two distinct phases are proposed. The first focuses on analysing possible causes and identifying actions, using an Ishikawa diagram, supported by a brainstorming session.
The second round focuses on the gradual development of an A3 document, which is built up step by step as the group responds structurally to the key questions of the analysis.
In conclusion, the facilitator explains the need to verify on the ground each of the hypotheses put forward, either directly or through a process of investigation with the person responsible for the process.
Although there is no single solution to the exercise, it is interesting to note that, through the questions they ask, all the teams tend to agree on what the main problem is.